Expectations are sky high in Austin for Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning entering the season, and the betting markets agree, as Manning is the +600 favorite to win the 2025 Heisman Trophy at BetMGM.

LSU QB Garrett Nussmeier and Clemson QB Cade Klubnik are tied at +900 for the next-best odds, followed by Ohio State wideout Jeremiah Smith.

Advertisement

There are plenty of options for Heisman value bets, but it’s always instructive of whether a player is outperforming or falling short of expectations to track how his Heisman odds are moving throughout the season.

Here are the Heisman odds for every college football player listed at BetMGM, entering the 2025-26 season:

Heisman Trophy odds

Arch Manning: +600

Garrett Nussemeier, Cade Klubnik: +900

Jeremiah Smith: 10-1

LaNorris Sellers: 16-1

Drew Allar, Julian Sayin, DJ Lagway: 18-1

Gunner Stockton, Sam Leavitt, Ty Simpson: 20-1

Carson Beck: 22-1

Dante Moore, John Mateer: 25-1

Jackson Arnold, Ryan Williams: 35-1

Advertisement

Austin Simmons, Marcel Reed, Avery Johnson, Dylan Raiola: 40-1

Miller Moss, Kevin Jennings, Jalon Daniels, Jeremiyah Love, Devon Dampier: 50-1

Fernando Mendoza: 55-1

Thomas Castellanos, Steve Angeli, Jayden Maiava: 66-1

Haynes King, Nico Iamaleava, Behren Morton: 80-1

Kyron Drones, Kaidon Salter: 90-1

100-1

Darian Mensah, Demond Williams Jr., Beau Pribula, Mikey Keene, Austin Mack

125-1

Jake Retzlaff, Rocco Becht, Diego Pavia, Mark Gronowski

150-1

Justice Haynes, Nate Frazier, Quintrevion Wisner, Eli Holstein, Cam Coleman, CJ Bailey

175-1

Caleb Downs

200-1

Connor Weigman, Noah Fifita

250-1

Rickie Collins, Aidan Chiles, Billy Edwards Jr., Evan Stewart, Josh Hoover

Advertisement

300-1

Kevin Concepcion, TJ Finley, Tayven Jackson, Dylan Edwards, Maalik Murphy

350-1

Zachariach Branch, Brendan Sorsby

400-1

Maddux Madsen, Hauss Hejny

500-1

Zach Calzada, Blake Horvath, Blake Shapen, Nick March