Photo courtesy of Hatch

Ah, pregnancy, so many exciting decisions to make! What color should you paint the nursery? Which breast pump should you buy? Do you really need a spatula to put cream on your baby’s bottom? And will any of these books actually work to get your baby to be a good sleeper? But before all of those decisions about the baby, you must make a crucial decision about yourself: to maternity jeans or not to maternity jeans.

Vogue’s Guide to the Best Maternity Jeans:

The Over-The-Bump

Madewell over-the-belly superwide-leg jeans

Jump to review

The Under-The-Bump

H&M Mama before & after straight low ankle jeans

Jump to review

During my own pregnancies, I tried my hardest to be the sort of person who “didn’t buy maternity clothes,” but that did not apply to jeans. In my non-pregnant life, I tend to go for rigid, high-rise jeans–if there are two words you want to avoid when it comes to pregnancy denim, it’s “rigid” and “high rise”–needless to say, I didn’t fit into any of my denim from very early on in my pregnancies. I did try the “rubber band trick” for a few weeks and then finally accepted defeat and purchased a pair of actual maternity jeans. It’s impossible to name the best maternity jeans out there because it is a very personal preference based on how you want your bump to feel. From over the bump to under it, here are the current best options on the market:

Over-the-Bump

Over-the-bump jeans tend to have a rather large amount of cotton or elastic fabric attached to the top of them that can feel very intimidating in the earlier stages of pregnancy, but will feel very necessary by the end. This style can be very divisive: some women prefer it as it feels protective over their bump and also seems to stay up better, while others feel suffocated by so much coverage and uncomfortable as the fabric often stretches all the way up to the bra line. I seem to recall describing the first pair of “over-the-bump” jeans I tried on as “claustrophobic,” but by the end of my pregnancy, they were the only ones I could wear. I’d recommend getting one pair with over-the-bump coverage if you plan to wear pants of any kind in the third trimester.

Under-the-Bump

Under-the-bump jeans are really just jeans with side elastic bits sewn in above the pockets or in lieu of pockets. These are ideal in the early and middle stages of pregnancy when you want to wear cute tops or sweaters and don’t want an extra layer of fabric underneath. The only caveat here is that, depending on how big your bump gets, these can slide down or not feel supportive enough towards the end of pregnancy. Many options in this category are strictly “skinny” jeans but I prefer the ones with a straight-leg or a slightly wider leg as they are definitely more flattering the closer you get to bowling ball status.

The Non-Maternity

Some pregnant women among us don’t even venture into the “maternity jean” category. I was definitely not one of these women, but they are out there. Rihanna, for example, lived in her Agolde low-slung baggy jeans throughout her very glamorous and bump-baring pregnancy. There are plenty of non-maternity options on the market that could work around a bump: any of the looser silhouettes or anything with an elastic or tie waistband could easily go below a bump and continue to inch further down as the months go on. These styles are also great for post-baby when you aren’t quite back into the rigid styles yet, but can’t possibly face your elastic ones again.

Overalls

Pregnancy overalls are making a comeback–Sofia Richie sported a chic pair during her pregnancy as did Hailey Bieber–and are a great option for comfort and ease; just be sure to find a pair that is easy to take on and off for those frequent trips to the bathroom. (A onesie-type jumpsuit is also a good one to have on hand. I loved to layer a button-down top over the Bumpsuit version.) Overalls also get bonus points as great options for breastfeeding once the babe has made it earthside!

The Non-Jeans

In addition to the abundance of maternity-specific denim on the market, there are also a few great options in non-denim areas that provide the same service. If you are already a leggings devotee, then don’t miss Bumpsuit’s maternity leggings. Kylie Jenner wore these in her pregnancy and paired them with just about everything. Leather maternity leggings are a great way to look a bit more polished or even a good choice for a “going out” look. There are even maternity shorts on the market these days, which would make a great option for stifling summer days!